Top 10 Payroll Errors and How to Avoid Them

Casey Webster • July 29, 2024

What are common risks associated with payroll?



Payroll is critical in any organization, ensuring that employees are paid accurately and on time. However, payroll errors can occur, leading to employee dissatisfaction, compliance issues, and financial penalties.  Here are the top 10 errors we find when completing a time and labor audit and how we correct the issues.


Incorrect Employee Information

  • Error: Mistakes in employee details such as names, addresses, Social Security numbers, and bank account information can lead to incorrect payments and tax issues.
  • Solution: Implement a robust onboarding process that includes verifying employee information. Regularly update records and use payroll software that flags incomplete or inconsistent data.


Misclassification of Employees

  • Error: Misclassifying employees as independent contractors or vice versa can result in incorrect tax withholdings and benefit allocations.
  • Solution: Understand the IRS's criteria for employee classification and ensure all employees are correctly categorized. Regularly review and audit classifications, especially when job roles change.


Inaccurate Time Tracking

  • Error: Failing to track employee hours, including overtime, accurately can lead to underpayment or overpayment.
  • Solution: Use reliable time-tracking systems and require employees to verify their hours worked. Implement automated systems that integrate with payroll software to reduce manual entry errors.


Overtime Miscalculations

  • Error: Incorrectly calculating overtime pay can result in compliance issues and dissatisfied employees.
  • Solution: Familiarize yourself with federal and state overtime regulations. Use payroll software that automatically calculates overtime based on the rules applicable to your location.


Incorrect Tax Withholding

  • Error: Errors in calculating and withholding taxes can lead to penalties and interest charges from tax authorities.
  • Solution: Stay updated with the latest tax laws and use payroll software to automate tax calculations. Conduct regular audits to ensure taxes are being withheld correctly.


Failure to Meet Deadlines

  • Error: Missing payroll deadlines can result in late employee payments and penalties for late tax filings.
  • Solution: Create a payroll calendar with all critical deadlines and ensure your team knows it. Use reminders and automated payroll systems to ensure timely processing.


Incomplete or Inaccurate Records

  • Error: Incomplete or inaccurate payroll records can cause compliance issues and make audits difficult.
  • Solution: Maintain thorough and accurate payroll records for each pay period. Use digital storage solutions that provide secure, easy access to records and back up data regularly.


Manual Processing Errors

  • Error: Manual payroll processing increases the risk of human error, such as incorrect data entry or calculation mistakes.
  • Solution: Use reliable payroll software to automate payroll processes as much as possible. Train your payroll team on best practices and ensure they double-check entries.


Benefits Mismanagement

  • Error: Incorrectly managing employee benefits, such as health insurance and retirement contributions, can lead to employee dissatisfaction and compliance issues.
  • Solution: Clearly communicate benefits information to employees and ensure payroll systems are correctly set up to handle deductions. Regularly review benefits plans and payroll deductions to ensure accuracy.


Non-Compliance with Wage and Hour Laws

  • Error: Failing to comply with wage and hour laws can result in legal penalties and back-pay obligations.
  • Solution: Stay informed about federal, state, and local wage and hour laws. Ensure your payroll system is set up to comply with these regulations and conduct regular audits.


Avoiding common payroll errors requires staying informed, using the right tools, and implementing effective processes. By addressing these common issues proactively, you can ensure your payroll operations run smoothly, keeping your employees satisfied and your organization compliant. Investing in reliable payroll software and training for your payroll team can significantly reduce the risk of errors, ultimately saving your organization time and money.


group of people putting hands together
By Casey Webster November 18, 2024
Learn how to create an employer brand that stays top of mind for talent—even when they're not actively job hunting. Discover practical strategies to embed your brand in the subconscious and attract the right candidates when they're ready for a change.
people and culture funnel
By Casey Webster November 5, 2024
In today’s competitive landscape, Human Resources is no longer just a support function—it’s a strategic powerhouse driving organizational growth. As businesses focus on building high-functioning teams, HR professionals are adopting proven sales techniques to attract, engage, and retain top talent. Enter the People & Culture Funnel, an innovative approach that mirrors the traditional sales funnel but is tailored for HR functions.
people listening to presentation
By Casey Webster October 21, 2024
Discover how HR professionals can use marketing principles like positioning, branding, and brand strategy to create a strong employer brand. Learn how to shape the perception of your company in the minds of candidates and employees, and deliver a consistent and compelling message both internally and externally.
Share by: